
(Somewhere) Over the Rainbow
ONE
One of the more onerous rituals of the annual Academy Awards telecast is the attempt to recreate onstage at the Kodak Theater the “lightning in a bottle” incandescence of the nominated songs. Though backed by glitzy production sets and dancers, the songs are stripped clean of their movie contexts. Whether sung in the movie itself, underscoring a montage, or embedded in a credit crawl, they were written to reflect, even enhance, the scene for which they were composed. In this respect the songs are close cousins to the best of Broadway musicals. Sometimes, these three-minute ballads even escape their celluloid bonds, becoming a part of American pop culture.
There is no song in all of American cinema that pulls you into its unfolding drama as successfully as Judy Garland’s “Over the Rainbow” from the 1939 film, The Wizard of Oz. But, this universally beloved song was very nearly cut from the movie.
Legend has it that after a preview, MGM studio chief Louis B. Mayer felt that the song “slowed down the picture” and “our star sings it in a barnyard.” True, it is sung very early in the movie, at a time when much of the audience had barely settled into their seats. In any case, a reprise of the song was cut from the finished film. An additional chorus (audio only), sung by Garland, trapped in the wicked witch’s castle, was released many years later in a deluxe edition of the soundtrack. The accompanying picture is believed lost.
A recent discussion of Over the Rainbow by Renee Montagne on the NPR morning news (in a version sung by the late Hawaiian, Israel Kamakawiwo’ole) is such an extreme departure from the classic Garland rendition, yet so successful, that it becomes a veritable re-creation of the song and a template for many cover versions. I began to consider why this song, above all other movie songs, has had such an enduring presence in American culture, so I decided to do a YouTube search, a kind of video jukebox, to hear a handful of the many variations possible. This took me to an earlier NPR story about how and why this song became a rite of passage for generations of American singers—a heartfelt “internal monologue” on life’s aspirations and dreams.
Continue reading ‘“Over the Rainbow”: A Video Jukebox’
Recent Comments